University of Illinois Student Legal Service Home Page

Security Deposit Games

Local Damage Deposit Games

While the start of a new semester means that a lot of your cash is leaving your possession,
you may be in a position to expect some money coming your way, from last year's landlord. Yes,
that security deposit could be on its way to you even as you read this. In fact, if you lived in a
building that contained 5 or more rental units, you should already have at least some idea of what
kind of refund to expect, if not the actual check in your hand. That's because your landlord has to
provide you, at the very least, notice of what he or she intends to withhold from the deposit
within 30 days of the expiration of your lease. If all you got was a list of estimated deductions,
then your landlord has to provide you with proof of the legitimacy of these deductions, plus a
check for the balance (if any) of your deposit within another 30 days.

That's what the law says, for buildings of 5 units or more. If you live in a house, for
example, these time constraints do not apply, and your landlord only needs to act on your deposit
in a reasonable amount of time. In either instance, though, if your landlord has made deductions
from your deposit it's important to take a close look at them and see if they're accurate, rational,
or even real. For instance, you may have thought you left your apartment in stupendous
condition, having cleaned every inch of every surface, dusted light bulbs, and vacuumed
windowsills. Aha! You forgot all about the little Tidy-Bowl boat in your toilet tank. The skipper
was shouting at the top of his little lungs "change me, change me," but you couldn't hear him due
to the drone of the vacuum cleaner. That means that the landlord's cleaning service had to do the
job, and one year tenants were charged $6.00 a pop for this delicate and difficult labor. Consider
the time it takes, and what hourly rate these people must be earning. It's enough to make you
scuttle your plans for medical school.

Of course, when you moved in, you noted in detail what came with your apartment, and
what didn't. Refer to that check-in sheet if you are now charged for missing closet doors,
microwaves, lamps, Nordic Traks, etc., which were never there to begin with.

The flip side of this business practice is something to be aware of as well. If you were
charged, say, $200.00 to have your old unit repainted, run, don't walk, back there to see if it was
in fact, painted. If it wasn't, why are you being charged? The landlord may say that painting is
"planned," and he or she just hasn't gotten to it yet. That is simply an inadequate explanation, and
you should get your money back.

Then there are charges that are just too strange to be believed. What do you make of a
$20.00 charge for "26 holes with liners," or $7.50 for "bush abuse"? And is it possible for it to
cost $25.00 to have someone pick up a plastic bag of trash and place it in a dumpster? We are
not making this up.

Of course, not all deductions are absurd or even particularly arguable. If there is a hole in
one of your walls that just happens to be the size and shape of your roommate, your landlord is
entitled to charge such repair against your deposit. And if you left your Rotweiler in your
apartment while you went to St. Louis for the weekend, you're going to have to pay for Fido's
damage.

If you sublet your apartment over the summer, consider damage your subtenants might
have caused. You may have left the place spotless in May; however, your subtenants could have
undone all your good work. The landlord can hold any and all of you responsible. If it goes to
court, the judge may be sympathetic, as in the case of tenants whose subs trashed the house over
the summer, leaving behind among other party favors, wall ornaments consisting of condoms.
The judge found the tenants liable, but did observe that the subs, while slovenly, appeared to have
had a pretty good time.

State law and local ordinance provide that, under certain circumstances, landlords who fail
to properly account for and return security deposits can be punished for their shortcomings. No,
you can't send them to their rooms, make them live in their own rental properties, or publish
written apologies in the DI. What you can do is hit where it really hurts, in the wallet. For
properties containing 5 units or more, the landlord must provide at least written estimates of
damages within 30 days of the termination of the lease. That buys them an additional thirty days
to provide proof of the repair of the damage and a check for the difference, if any. If this is not
done, then the landlord must refund the deposit in full. That in itself can be a penalty; but wait,
there's more. If you feel that your landlord refused to provide a statement of damages, or has
provided you with one in bad faith, and one of our local judges agrees with you, then the landlord
is liable to you for your deposit times two, plus court costs, plus your attorney's fees.

But wait, there's more. For properties containing more than 25 units, state law provides
that the landlord must accrue and pay interest on your deposit, at the prevailing rate of interest. If
this is not done and paid to you within 30 days of the termination of your lease, the potential
penalty is an amount equal to your deposit, plus interest, plus court costs and attorney's fees.
However, there's a catch; you cannot be in default in your obligations under the lease. Therefore,
if you or any of your roommates owe rent, you have no legal right to seek this remedy.

If you live in Urbana, almost all rental property is subject to an Urbana city ordinance
which provides identical protection for tenants. Some limitations exist: the deposit must be at
least $100.00, and the property must not be owner-occupied containing 3 units or less.

The point here is to read security deposit accountings with a critical eye, following up
whenever possible to verify the alleged repairs, and to be suspicious of deductions that just don't
make sense, no matter how small the charge. Student Legal Service is available to discuss all
these issues with you, and to assist you in getting a fair return..